[Russia, which provided the fuel to Iran, said earlier this month that the worm’s infection of the reactor should be investigated, arguing that it might trigger a nuclear disaster. Other experts said those fears were overblown, but noted that the full workings of the Stuxnet worm remained unclear.]
By WILLIAM J. BROAD and DAVID E. SANGER
The reactor building at the Bushehr nuclear plant in Iran. Operation of the long-anticipated facility has been delayed |
In a report on Friday, the International Atomic Energy Agency said Iran told inspectors on Wednesday that it was planning to unload nuclear fuel from its Bushehr reactor — the sign of a major upset. For years, Tehran has hailed the reactor as a showcase of its peaceful nuclear intentions and its imminent startup as a sign of quickening progress.
But nuclear experts said the giant reactor, Iran’s first nuclear power plant, now threatens to become a major embarrassment, as engineers remove 163 fuel rods from its core.
Iran gave no reason for the unexpected fuel unloading, but it has previously admitted that the Stuxnet computer worm infected the Bushehr reactor. On Friday, computer experts debated whether Stuxnet was responsible for the surprising development.
Russia, which provided the fuel to Iran, said earlier this month that the worm’s infection of the reactor should be investigated, arguing that it might trigger a nuclear disaster. Other experts said those fears were overblown, but noted that the full workings of the Stuxnet worm remained unclear.
In interviews Friday, nuclear experts said the trouble behind the fuel unloading could range from minor safety issues and operational ineptitude to serious problems that would bring the reactor’s brief operational life to a premature end.
“It could be simple and embarrassing all the way to ‘game over,’ ” said David A. Lochbaum, a nuclear engineer at the Union of Concerned Scientists and a former official at theNuclear Regulatory Commission, which oversees nuclear reactors in the United States.
Mr. Lochbaum added that having to unload a newly fueled reactor was “not unprecedented, but not an everyday occurrence.” He said it happened perhaps once in every 25 or 30 fuelings. In Canada, he added, a reactor was recently fueled and scrapped after the belated discovery of serious technical problems.
“This could represent a substantial setback to their program,” David Albright, president of the Institute for Science and International Security, a private group in Washington that tracks nuclear proliferation, said of the problem behind the Bushehr upset.
“It raises questions of whether Iran can operate a modern nuclear reactor safely,” he added. “The stakes are very high. You can have a Chernobyl-style accident with this kind of reactor, and there’s lots of questions about that possibility in the region.”
The new report from the I.A.E.A. — a regular quarterly review of the Iran nuclear program to the agency’s board — gave the reactor unloading only brief mention and devoted its bulk to an unusually toughly worded indictment of Iranian refusals to answer questions about what the inspectors called “possible military dimensions” of its nuclear program.
The report alluded to “new information recently received,” suggesting continuing work toward a nuclear warhead.
But the inspectors provided no details about the new information or how it was received. The I.A.E.A. frequently gets its data from the intelligence agencies of member countries, including the United States, but it also tries to collect data from its own sources.
The report on Friday referred directly to concerns that Iran was working on “the development of a nuclear payload for a missile.” But it noted that all of its requests for information had been ignored for years, with Iranian officials arguing that whatever information the agency possessed, it was based on forgeries.
The White House said Friday that the report cast new light on what it called Iran’s covert movement toward nuclear arms.
“The I.A.E.A.’s reports of obstruction and Iran’s failure to cooperate are troubling,” said Tommy Vietor, spokesman for the National Security Council. “We will continue to hold Iran accountable to its international nuclear obligations, including by deepening the international pressure on Iran.”
The reactor is located outside the Iranian city of Bushehr on the nation’s Persian Gulf coast. Priced at more than a billion dollars, it is ringed by dozens of antiaircraft guns and large radar stations meant to track approaching jets.
Its tangled history began around 1975 with a West German contract. After the Islamic Revolution in 1979, the West Germans withdrew. Iraq repeatedly bombed the half-built reactor between 1984 and 1988.
Iran signed a rebuilding accord with Russia in 1995 that should have had the project completed in 1999. But the plan bogged down in long delays.
The United States once opposed the plant. But Washington dropped its objections after Russia agreed to take back the spent rods, removing the possibility that Iran could reprocess them for materials that could fuel nuclear arms.
The loading of uranium fuel into the reactor was initially planned to start soon after its shipment to Bushehr last August, but was delayed by what the Iranians said was a leak in a pool near the central reactor.
In October, Iranian officials said the Stuxnet worm had infected the reactor complex, but they played down the issue. Mohammad Ahmadian, an Iranian Atomic Energy Organization official, said the affected computers had been “inspected and cleaned up.”
Later in October, as the fueling at last got under way, after three decades of delay, the head of Iran’s Atomic Energy Organization, Ali Akbar Salehi, called the Bushehr reactor “the most exceptional power plant in the world.”
In December, he predicted that the plant would be connected to the national power grid by Feb. 19. “This phase,” he said, according to The Tehran Times, “is the most important operational work of the plant.”
In an interview on Friday, a European diplomat familiar with Iran’s nuclear program called the fueling problem a major setback, even if the technical cause proves to be less than monumental.
“It’s clearly a significant setback to the startup of the reactor,” said the diplomat, who spoke on the condition of anonymity because of the diplomatic delicacy of the matter.
He said that engineers at Bushehr had identified a technical failure, but were struggling to understand its cause.
“It’s too early to know,” the diplomat said. “I’m sure the Iranians are studying that question quite desperately.”
SIXTY-TWO NEPALIS RETURN FROM LIBYA, OTHERS WAITING TURN
By Yadav Raj Joshi, The Himalayan Times
KATHMANDU: The first batch of Nepali migrant workers who were forced to leave restive Mediterranean country Libya and stranded in Egypt for over a week returned home with the help of their employers, manpower agency and the Nepali mission in Egypt.
Sixty-two labourers working for the A-One Construction, a South Korean company, landed in the Tribhuvan International Airport on Saturday, boarding an Air Arabia plane.
The SOS Manpower Service Pvt Ltd and A-One Construction bore their airfare from the Egyptian city of Alexandria to Kathmandu, First Vice-President of Nepal Association of Foreign Employment Agencies (NAFEA) Hansha Raj Wagle informed.
The government has spent USD 30,000 to rescue the Nepali nationals working in Libya to Egyptian border cities of Sallum and Alexandria.
According to Wagle, the SOS Manpower has chartered two flights of Air Arabia to rescue 500 others from Egypt to Nepal tomorrow.
Ministry of Labour and Transport Management (MoLTM) said the government is carrying out the rescue operation in coordination with the manpower agencies. “The state is equally involved in the operation as it is its responsibility,” said Joint-Secretary at MoLTM Purna Chandra Bhattarai.
About 562 Nepalis working for the construction company were left high and dry after their quarters were burnt by locals last month, and further pushed to face the difficulties compounded in the wake of anti-government protest about two weeks ago or so in Libya.
Meanwhile, the fate of around 2,400 Nepalis stranded in Egypt and Libya is still uncertain as the government is yet to decide how to rescue them.
“We have agreed to rescue all 3,024 workers from Libya but mechanism for it is not developed,” said Bhattarai.
According Joint Secretary of Ministry of Foreign Affairs (MoFA) Durga Prasad Bhattarai, the Nepali Embassy in Egypt is building up communication with the workers working in Libya for their rescue.
[About 562 Nepalis working for the construction company were left high and dry after their quarters were burnt by locals last month, and further pushed to face the difficulties compounded in the wake of anti-government protest about two weeks ago or so in Libya.]
KATHMANDU: The first batch of Nepali migrant workers who were forced to leave restive Mediterranean country Libya and stranded in Egypt for over a week returned home with the help of their employers, manpower agency and the Nepali mission in Egypt.
Sixty-two labourers working for the A-One Construction, a South Korean company, landed in the Tribhuvan International Airport on Saturday, boarding an Air Arabia plane.
The SOS Manpower Service Pvt Ltd and A-One Construction bore their airfare from the Egyptian city of Alexandria to Kathmandu, First Vice-President of Nepal Association of Foreign Employment Agencies (NAFEA) Hansha Raj Wagle informed.
The government has spent USD 30,000 to rescue the Nepali nationals working in Libya to Egyptian border cities of Sallum and Alexandria.
According to Wagle, the SOS Manpower has chartered two flights of Air Arabia to rescue 500 others from Egypt to Nepal tomorrow.
Ministry of Labour and Transport Management (MoLTM) said the government is carrying out the rescue operation in coordination with the manpower agencies. “The state is equally involved in the operation as it is its responsibility,” said Joint-Secretary at MoLTM Purna Chandra Bhattarai.
About 562 Nepalis working for the construction company were left high and dry after their quarters were burnt by locals last month, and further pushed to face the difficulties compounded in the wake of anti-government protest about two weeks ago or so in Libya.
Meanwhile, the fate of around 2,400 Nepalis stranded in Egypt and Libya is still uncertain as the government is yet to decide how to rescue them.
“We have agreed to rescue all 3,024 workers from Libya but mechanism for it is not developed,” said Bhattarai.
According Joint Secretary of Ministry of Foreign Affairs (MoFA) Durga Prasad Bhattarai, the Nepali Embassy in Egypt is building up communication with the workers working in Libya for their rescue.