[The industry is also facing uncertainty in China, another enormous market. Alarmed by a series of media reports that many young people were using e-cigarettes, the country’s National Health and Family Planning Commission has said that it is considering regulation. This week, Juul said that its products were no longer available on some major Chinese e-commerce sites, though private merchants were still selling them on the Taobao platform.]
By Maria Abi-Habib and Shalini Venugopal
 |
|
An
e-cigarette for sale at a roadside shop in New Delhi. India has one of the
highest
rates
of tobacco use in the world. Credit Manish Swarup/Associated Press
|
NEW
DELHI — India on Wednesday
moved a step closer to a nationwide ban on electronic cigarettes, part of a
global backlash amid growing concern about the health risks posed by vaping.
The ban could shut the door to a lucrative
market for e-cigarette manufacturers such as Juul at a time when they are
facing increased scrutiny and regulation in the United States. India has one of
the highest rates of tobacco use in the world, according to the World Health
Organization, with nearly 100 million smokers and another 200 million users of
chewing tobacco and other such products.
The new regulations still require
parliamentary approval, but they are expected to pass when lawmakers meet in
November. Juul, an e-cigarette market leader, had planned to formally unveil
its products in India later this year.
“Envisioned as a tool to combat tobacco
addiction, electronic cigarettes and other vaping products have become a major
problem and increase the risk of children adopting them,” Finance Minister
Nirmala Sitharaman said on Wednesday at a news conference.
“Reports say that there are some who are
probably getting into the habit of e-cigarettes as it seems cool,” she added.
The proposed law would ban the sale,
production, import, transportation and advertisement of electronic cigarettes,
punishing first-time offenders with either a one-year jail term or a $1,400
fine, or both. A repeat violation would incur a three-year jail sentence and a
$7,000 fine, the government said.
E-cigarettes have come under the microscope
after a recent spate of vaping-related illnesses in the United States, killing
at least seven people so far. On Monday, California’s governor said the state
would increase its efforts to regulate e-cigarettes.
The industry is also facing uncertainty in
China, another enormous market. Alarmed by a series of media reports that many
young people were using e-cigarettes, the country’s National Health and Family
Planning Commission has said that it is considering regulation. This week, Juul
said that its products were no longer available on some major Chinese
e-commerce sites, though private merchants were still selling them on the
Taobao platform.
Critics say that electronic cigarettes are
often marketed as a healthier alternative to smoking but that they still pose
significant health risks. They say children are often attracted to the various
flavors — like mango or watermelon — and bright colors that vaping products
come in, potentially addicting them to nicotine before they pick up their first
cigarette.
“The whole idea of e-cigarettes was to reduce
smoking, but that’s a farce,” said Anil Purohit, chief executive of the Jodhpur
School of Public Health in India. “In reality, it’s drawing kids in and
addicting them. The industry has become a sort of fashion, you can buy
e-cigarettes in any color or flavor and you see all these young people floating
around with these fancy gadgets.”
He added, “By the time kids reach high
school, they graduate from e-cigarettes to cigarette use.”
But skeptics doubt that India will be able to
implement a ban, particularly in rural areas where smoking is most prevalent.
Sixteen of India’s 29 states have banned vaping products, but they are still
prevalent in stores and available for purchase online.
“In India, marijuana has been banned for
decades, but India is one of the biggest weed users in the world; Delhi and
Mumbai have some of the highest weed consumption,” said Samrat Chowdhery,
director of the Association of Vapers India, which promotes e-cigarettes as a
healthier alternative to tobacco.
Mr. Chowdhery said vaping products were like
nicotine patches or gum: important tools for those trying to kick a tobacco
habit. Any harm caused, he argues, would be negligible compared to the dangers
of continuing to smoke cigarettes.
Opponents of a ban say the new regulations
would only force e-cigarettes onto the black market, where the products would
be harder to regulate. “And we won’t know what’s actually inside these
products,” Mr. Chowdhery added.
Praveen Rikhy, the head of Trends, a trade
body representing importers, distributors and sellers of e-cigarettes in India,
said her group would lobby lawmakers before the November vote. Ms. Rikhy
criticized the central government for drawing up the legislation without
consulting e-cigarette sellers or manufacturers, saying that vaping products
were “the lowest-hanging fruit to go after.”
“Chewing tobacco has not been banned and
smoking cigarettes has not been banned,” she said.
Sui-Lee Wee contributed reporting from
Beijing.
