Government crackdown in Guangdong could backfire by
crippling groups that channel worker anger into peaceful protest, say rights
groups and analysts
By Tom Phillips
Workers outside a factory during a 2014 strike in Guangdong province Photograph: Reuters |
Chinese campaigners have called on Beijing to free five
prominent labour activists after police launched an “unprecedented” crackdown
designed to neuter their movement at a time of growing worker unrest.
At least 18 Guangdong-based campaigners have
been detained or interrogated since last Thursday when police began their
roundup in China ’s factory
heartlands.
Those who remain in custody include Zeng
Feiyang, director of the Panyu Workers’ Centre in the provincial capital
Guangzhou; He Xiaobo, who runs a support group for injured workers in the
nearby city of Foshan; and Zhu Xiaomei, a female activist from the same
organisation who is also the mother of a one-year-old baby.
Also being held are Deng Xiaoming, from the
Haige Workers’ Services Centre, andPeng Jiayong, who runs the Panyu Labourer
Mutual Aid Group. Chen Huihai, a sixth activist, is understood to be under
house arrest.
William Nee, a Hong Kong-based activist for
Amnesty International, said “a coordinated attack” on Guangdong ’s labour movement
was under way.
“We always had problems, groups would always
be temporarily shut down or harassed or sometimes temporarily detained … [but] this
is definitely unprecedented,” Nee said.
“This is the only time that I can remember in
recent years in which many labour activists and organisations – without any
kind of incident pre-empting it – have all of a sudden been taken in one fell
swoop.”
In an open letter published on Thursday
morning, activists urged the Communist party’s senior leadership to end the
“terrible crackdown” and return the arrested activists to their loved ones.
“In Guangdong there have been
cases where staff from workers’ rights groups were slashed, beaten, put under
administrative or criminal detention or where these organisations were forced
to move, were harassed or had their licences cancelled,” the letter said. “But
this is the first time in Guangdong or indeed the
whole country that there has been such a severe crackdown on a such scale from
the government.”
One close friend of the detained activists, who
declined to be named because of the risk of arrest, said she had been stunned
by the severity of the police operation.
“I felt shocked. Before [the activists] would
be summoned for a chat … but this time they came to their houses to detain them,
put handcuffs on their wrists and took them away. I couldn’t believe it when I
heard. I felt afraid.”
The detentions come at a time of rising
worker unrest in what is one of the world’s most important manufacturing hubs.
There were 301 strikes in November –
including a record 56 in Guangdong – according to
advocacy group China Labour Bulletin.
Experts blame the spike in discontent on
factories that are closing or relocating to south-east Asia as a result of the
spluttering economy and rising wages.
Tim Pringle, an expert in China’s labour
movement from the School of Oriental and African Studies, said he believed the
decision to detain some of Guangdong’s most experienced activists was linked to
the region’s economic transformation.
“As the economic climate changes … the
government probably feels there is less room to manoeuvre in the coming 12 to 18
months. So it is probably cleaning the house, saying, ‘Let’s get these guys out
the way so we can deal with the downturn in the economy with less pressure’.
“When
you are dealing with factory closures and people losing their jobs and their
livelihoods … you are dealing with a situation that is less predictable. And I
think that makes the government very nervous.”
Nee said it was not yet clear whether the
crackdown had been instigated by provincial authorities in Guangdong or was part of a
wider Beijing-led crackdown related to President Xi Jinping’s sweeping
offensive against potential Communist party foes.
Since Xi took power three years ago security
forces have targeted a wide range of civil society groups including human
rights lawyers, journalists, NGOs and religious leaders.
“It’s a very short-sighted move. It is not
going to stem the tide of labour unrest and strikes,” Nee said of the latest
crackdown. “There will continue to be strikes. Workers will continue to be angry.
“What organisations like [these] were doing
was taking workers and trying to provide ways that they could organise and not
cause destruction to society – preventing them from blocking roads and taking
other extreme actions like kidnapping bosses and instead trying to work out
their solutions through dialogue, with both the employers and with local
government.
“If there aren’t people like that providing
these types of services there is a greater risk of social instability spilling
over in ways that the government doesn’t want to see.”
Pringle said he believed the wave of
detentions was an attempt to “constrain and control” Guangdong ’s labour movement.
“These guys always act under risky
circumstances but this is certainly an upping of the level of repression and
constriction,” he said.
“The Chinese state is very happy with a civil
society that provides services … but they are much less happy when civil
society groups become activists and try to organise people to protect their
lawful rights and interests.”
The Guangdong activist insisted
her friends and colleagues had been engaged in a peaceful fight for workers’
legitimate rights. “They did not encourage workers to jump from rooftops or to
block the traffic in order to protect their rights,” she said.
“I thought they played a positive role. [But]
the government seems to think differently.”
Additional reporting by Christy Yao