[In refusing to name a chief-ministerial
candidate, the BJP has ensured that Mr Modi is testing his personal magic
against the local champions of Bihar . If he wins, the BJP will score a crucial few seats in the upper house of
the national parliament, which has proved adept in thwarting him. If he loses, he
and his opponents nationwide will be recalibrating strategy in years to come.]
The Economist Explains
ON OCTOBER 12th, India 's notoriously
backward state of Bihar begins a near month-long election for its state assembly. With 66m people
eligible to vote over five phases of polling, across some of the densest and
roughest bits of north India , the election
was never going to be easy. Despite being home to a population larger than that
of any country in western Europe, Bihar remains stubbornly sub-national in its politics. Campaigns are rife with
cults of personality and coalition-building on the basis of castes that hold
little sway elsewhere. So why is everyone in India watching this
state as if the future of the republic were at stake?
One reason for the wide
interest is that this year’s vote has brought some of India ’s most
colourful political rivals into combat. The prime minister, Narendra Modi (pictured),
has risked his own stature by leading his Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) into
battle against an odd alliance of erstwhile enemies: the technocratic chief
minister of Bihar, Nitish Kumar, who used to ally with the BJP but broke over
Mr Modi’s ascent; and the wildly charismatic and corrupt Lalu Prasad Yadav, his
predecessor. The setting is equally dramatic. Bihar has long lagged on every social indicator and is
often used within India as a byword for misgovernance and backwardness. But since 2005, with the
start of Mr Kumar’s reign, Bihar has scored several years of double-digit growth, outpacing and inspiring
the rest of the country.
What makes this race
important in Delhi , the capital, is the way it has become a test of Mr Modi’s prestige
against the most formidable opposition he is likely to face in his first term
as prime minister. The BJP had never captured any sort of majority in Bihar until last year, when it swept aside both Mr
Kumar’s party and Mr Yadav's loyal voters, winning most of the state’s
parliamentary seats in a general election. In the previous state election, in 2010,
the pre-Modi BJP won just 91 of 243 seats in the state assembly. Will the
momentum hold? Sensing a powerful foe in Mr Modi, Messrs Kumar and Yadav, who
detested one another openly in the past, formed a “grand alliance”. (The BJP’s
national rival, Congress, has joined too, but the campaign led by its scion, Rahul
Gandhi, has shown little flair.) In refusing to name a chief-ministerial
candidate, the BJP has ensured that Mr Modi is testing his personal magic
against the local champions of Bihar . If he wins, the BJP will score a crucial few seats in the upper house of
the national parliament, which has proved adept in thwarting him. If he loses, he
and his opponents nationwide will be recalibrating strategy in years to come.
The vote counting will not
start counted until November 8 th. Analysts will be eager to interpret the
verdict as either victory or defeat for Mr Modi’s national agenda of economic
development. This will be complicated by the fact that many Biharis credit Mr
Kumar for their state’s recent progress. But other things are at stake too: in
the past few weeks an ugly spate of anti-Muslim violence elsewhere in north
India, most strikingly the lynching of a man accused by his neighbours of
eating beef (which is legal), has changed the equation. The BJP has been
shamefully silent about the killing. Even when Mr Modi spoke of it on October 8th,
he was elliptical and deflected blame from his Hindu-nationalist allies who
expressed sympathy with the murderers. There is an electoral logic to this
pandering. the BJP wants to divide the Muslims and Hindus within Mr Yadav's
coalition. While both sides can mount arguments about development, neither is
above playing the old cards of caste and community.
@ The Economist
Bihar will witness a five-phase election following which
poll results will be declared on November 8. The second phase of polling will
take place on October 16. After that, there will a short break because of Durga
Puja and Muharram. The third phase will commence on October 28, followed by
November 1. The fifth and last day of voting will take place on November 5. Monday’s
election sealed the fate of 583 candidates, many of whom are Independents. Stung
by allegation of corruption against one of its ministers Awadhesh Kushwaha (now
dropped from the Cabinet), the ruling JD (U)’s prestige is at stake as in 2010
Assembly elections, it had won 29 seats out of 49 constituencies where voting
took place on Monday.
[The BJP, which is trying to
cash in on Narendra Modi wave against Nitish-led alliance, had won 13 seats in 2010.
This time the saffron brigade is contesting elections in alliance with the LJP,
RLSP and the HAM.]
By Abhay Kumar
Amid poll boycott call given
by the Maoists, the first phase of elections for Bihar ’s 49 constituencies passed off peacefully.
According to Election
Commission sources, 57 per cent of the electorate on Monday came out to cast
their votes in different constituencies spread over 10 districts in the state.
Additional Chief Electoral
Officer (ACEO) R Lakshmanan said turnout of woman voters was relatively more
compared to previous poll. “In all, 59.5 per cent woman voters turned up while 54.5
per cent male electorate cast their votes,” the ACEO said.
“The senior-most voter who
exercised her franchise on Monday was 108-year-old Maharani Devi at Teghra
Assembly constituency in Begusarai,” said chief electoral officer Ajay Nayak
here on Monday.
The BJP, which is trying to
cash in on Narendra Modi wave against Nitish-led alliance, had won 13 seats in 2010.
This time the saffron brigade is contesting elections in alliance with the LJP,
RLSP and the HAM.
The Congress’s credibility
too is at stake as the first phase of polling took place in Bhagalpur from where its sitting MLA
Ajit Sharma faces a formidable BJP candidate Arjit Shashwat, son of BJP MP
Ashwani Choubey. The fate of former Assembly Speaker and senior-most Congress
leader Sadanand Singh, who is an MLA since 1969, has also been sealed from
Kahalgaon.
Altogether 725 companies, including
189 companies of the CRPF and 115 companies of the CISF, were deployed to
ensure free and fair elections in all the 10 districts, out of which six –
Nawada, Jamui, Lakhisarai, Banka, Khagaria and Munger – are Maoist-affected.