[Pakistani officials have expressed hope that Mr. Modi,who has a reputation as a hard-liner, and the Bharatiya Janata Party will seize
an opportunity to rebuild ties, precisely because he is much less vulnerable to
charges of weakness. The relationship improved the
last time the B.J.P. took power, in 1998, under Prime Minister Atal
Bihari Vajpayee.]
By Ellen Barry
Mr. Modi, a Hindu nationalist who promised in his campaign to make India a more muscular presence on the world stage, has broken new ground by inviting the leaders of all of India’s neighbors.
Previous swearing-in ceremonies have been small affairs,
a reflection of the country’s inward-looking approach to politics. Mr. Modi has
made it clear that he hopes to make India a leader in its own neighborhood, knitting together a
regional trade and economic bloc.
The
invitation to Mr. Sharif, who has never made an official visit to India , was the biggest surprise. A tentative effort to build
economic and diplomatic ties under Prime Minister Manmohan Singh of the Indian
National Congress fell apart last year, when deadly skirmishes broke out along
the contested border in Kashmir . Mr. Singh, usually soft-spoken, declared that “after
this dastardly act, there can’t be business as usual with Pakistan .”
Pakistani officials have expressed hope that Mr. Modi,
who has a reputation as a hard-liner, and the Bharatiya Janata Party will seize
an opportunity to rebuild ties, precisely because he is much less vulnerable to
charges of weakness. The relationship improved the
last time the B.J.P. took power, in 1998, under Prime Minister Atal
Bihari Vajpayee.
“We did have very good relations with Vajpayee,” said a
Pakistani Foreign Ministry official, who spoke on the condition of anonymity
because of the sensitivity of the matter. “Congress is always looking at its
back when dealing with Pakistan because it was open to an attack from the right wing.
But B.J.P. would never face that barrage of criticism.”
“It would be like Nixon in China ,” the official said.
Stephen P. Cohen, author of a recent book on the relationship
between Pakistan and India, said Mr. Sharif would probably reciprocate Mr.
Modi’s gesture, but only if he can win the support of Pakistan’s powerful
military.
“I think we might see a dialogue between Modi and
Sharif,” Mr. Cohen said. “But Sharif has an army problem, and Modi has a
right-wing ideological problem.”
During the campaign, Mr. Modi attacked the Congress-led
government for maintaining high-level contact with Pakistan despite the clashes on the border in Kashmir ,
at one point saying, “Heads of our soldiers are cut, but then their prime
minister is fed chicken biryani.”
The foreign policy experts clustered around Mr. Modi have
urged him to adopt a tougher military stance in the region. One adviser, former
Foreign Secretary Kanwal Sibal, urged him in a recent article to “develop the necessary military
sinews to pursue a more robust foreign policy, including accelerating our
strategic programs and climbing down from the nuclear disarmament bandwagon.”
But others say Mr. Modi’s ambitious development agenda
will require India to improve relations with its neighbors by opening
markets and normalizing trade across the subcontinent’s borders.
“There are a whole lot of people who bet on Modi being a
hard-liner and are catering to that,” said C. Raja Mohan, a foreign-policy
analyst. “Modi is not coming in to pick a fight with Pakistan . He wants to show that he can run this country and do
whatever it takes to promote India ’s regional interests. This is a good way of starting.”
A Congress spokesman praised the decision to invite Mr.
Sharif, as did the state government and opposition parties in
Indian-administered Kashmir .
“This is a huge gesture,” said Mahbooba Mufti, a Kashmiri
opposition leader. “It is a very pleasant surprise, a very good beginning. If
Mr. Modi can take some concrete steps in improving relations with Pakistan , he will be remembered in history.”
Rasul Bakhsh Rais, an analyst in Islamabad , said Mr. Sharif was serious about normalizing relations
with India , which he regards as a precondition to domestic
progress, “but he is cautious because of the security apparatus here.” He added
that he did not expect Mr. Modi to govern as a hard-liner, despite the tough
rhetoric he used in the campaign.
“Modi is pragmatic, a go-getter and different from R.S.S.
and other Hindu extremist groups,” he said, referring to the Rashtriya
Swayamsevak Sangh. “Using political language to come to power is something
else, and formulating policy once in power is something else.”
G. Parthasarathy, a retired diplomat who has served as India ’s ambassador to Pakistan , warned against reading too much into the invitation to
Mr. Sharif.
He predicted that Mr. Modi would be “very
terrorism-focused” in his interactions with Pakistan and that he would not
engage in any dialogue until India’s security concerns were addressed, in part
because his “whole constituency is very tough” on Pakistan. What was more
important, he said, was that Mr. Modi had sent a message to the region’s
leaders expressing his desire to pursue a much greater degree of economic
integration.
“This has never happened before in our history, that you
invite all your neighbors to your swearing-in,” Mr. Parthasarathy said. “It’s
the gesture which matters at this stage.”
Hari
Kumar contributed reporting from New Delhi ,
Declan Walsh from London , and
Salman Masood from Islamabad , Pakistan .