[This religious crusade is rapidly
gaining popular support and could threaten the country’s stability.]
On the morning of Dec. 3, the
resentments at Rajco Industries exploded into mob violence. Word spread across
the factory that Kumara, preparing to repaint the walls for a visiting
delegation, had taken down some religious posters that praised the prophet
Muhammad and tossed them in the trash — thus committing an act of blasphemy.
Enraged by rumors of Kumara’s
offense, several hundred workers chased him onto the factory roof and then
dragged him into the yard, where they beat, stoned and kicked him to death,
then set his crumpled corpse on fire.
The grisly incident highlighted a
dangerous streak of radicalization that is spreading among ordinary, lower-income
and nonmilitant Muslims, according to observers in Pakistan. Some say this
trend is a greater threat to Pakistan’s stability than the armed, pro-Taliban
militias that have been challenging state security forces for years. Unlike the
militants’ agenda, the anti-blasphemy cause enjoys wide support in this
majority-Muslim nation of 220 million.
Amid the chaotic attack in Sialkot,
security cameras and television news videos recorded workers taking selfies and
chanting religious slogans. “We told the foreman what [Kumara] had done, but he
ran away. Then we all rushed to find the manager, and we sent him to hell,” one
young worker, flushed with righteous bravado, explained to several TV crews
that arrived before he was arrested. Other workers crowded around, and several
shouted, “I am here in the service of the Prophet,” the slogan of a radical
Muslim movement.
The killing shocked the country,
drawing swift condemnation from political, civic and religious leaders of all
stripes. Prime Minister Imran Khan denounced the “horrific vigilante attack”
and said it had brought a “day of shame” to Pakistan.
Khan vowed that the perpetrators
would be punished “with full severity of the law,” and he publicly awarded a
certificate “for courage and valor” to a junior factory manager who had tried
to hold back the mob. The government sent Kumara’s remains home to Colombo with
full state honors, and officials from Sri Lanka — one of Pakistan’s few regional
allies and a major economic partner — expressed confidence that Pakistani
authorities would do justice in his death.
Sialkot police, who had been slow
to reach the factory and were criticized for failing to stop the attackers,
launched investigations with the help of several other police agencies, using
security videos to identify attackers. In the past two weeks, more than 100
suspects have been arrested, all young men who worked at Rajco, and a smaller
number are being held for prosecution in anti-terrorism courts.
“The fury of the attackers was
frightening. Some of them might be punished, but it is the impunity for rising
religiously inspired violent extremism that will keep producing tragedies like
Sialkot,” columnist Zahid Hussain wrote in Dawn newspaper. The “weaponization
of faith” is the main reason for the spread of such brutality in society, he
wrote, adding that the state’s “policy of appeasement” has made it worse.
In the past decade, millions of
Pakistanis have been caught up in the religious fervor of an anti-blasphemy
campaign, launched after a liberal politician named Salman Taseer was
assassinated by his own bodyguard for his denunciation of the harsh legal
punishment of a Christian peasant woman accused of blasphemy.
The anti-blasphemy group built a
cult around the bodyguard, Mumtaz Qadri. After he was hanged for murder in
2016, they declared him a martyr for Islam, built a shrine near the capital,
Islamabad, and formed a new political party, Tehrik-e-Labbaik Pakistan. Since
then, Labbaik’s leaders have staged increasingly large, aggressive protests across
the country and rapidly gained electoral support.
First, in 2017, these party leaders
challenged a change in election laws that weakened requirements for candidates
to declare their faith. After protesters blocked a major highway for weeks, the
government, then led by Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif, backed off and made peace
with Labbaik leaders. In 2019, the group staged protests when Asia Bibi, the
woman championed by Taseer, was freed after 10 years on death row and allowed
to flee to the West.
In 2020, Labbaik supporters again
occupied highways and bridges, this time protesting the publication of
anti-Muslim cartoons in France and demanding that the French ambassador to
Pakistan be expelled. The disruption continued until last month, when the Khan
government finally agreed to drop Labbaik’s leader, Saad Rizvi, from a
terrorism watch list and released him from prison.
Labbaik’s leaders have repeatedly
declared that they do not condone violence, yet they also preach that
blasphemers deserve to die, and their crusade has inspired incidents of murder
and arson. At a college campus in northwest Pakistan, a secular student was
accused of blasphemy and beaten to death by classmates in 2017. A few days
before the Sialkot attack, a mob burned down a police station in the northwest
after officials refused to hand over a prisoner accused of blasphemy.
In an interview this week at an
Islamic seminary in the city of Rawalpindi, Syed Enayatul Haq Shah, a senior
official of Labbaik, asserted that the group had “nothing to do” with the mob
attack in Sialkot, which he attributed to the natural outrage of Muslims when
they believe the prophet Muhammad has been insulted. The group’s name
translates as “Here in the Service of the Prophet.”
“We have always been peaceful, and
we never preach violence,” Shah said. “To a Muslim, the biggest crime in the
world is insulting the Prophet, but it is up to the state to take action.
Instead, people see the judicial system failing to act in these cases. They see
the government under pressure from Western liberal forces to change the law.
They cannot bear it, and sometimes they take the law into their own hands.”
Pakistan’s anti-blasphemy law is
harsh, calling for death when the case has been proved. People can spend years
in prison on mere accusations of insulting Islam, such as making a joke or
dropping a Koran. The law is also misused to target Christians and other
minorities, especially from the Ahmadi sect, in cases of personal or community
grudges.
A top religious adviser to the
government, Allama Hafiz Tahir Ashrafi, said officials have been encouraged by
the broad array of groups that condemned the Sialkot attack, including Labbaik.
He said that he and others are working to counter anti-blasphemy radicalism
through dialogue but that Islamic fervor has taken deep root in Pakistan and
will be difficult to counter.
“This is not the product of one
day. It is a disease that has grown during 40 years,” said Ashrafi, the prime
minister’s special representative on religious harmony. “There is so much
ignorance and unemployment. People take advantage of it.” But he also said the
West should not press Pakistan too hard on the blasphemy issue because that
will backfire. “It will take time, but we can put our own house in order,” he
said.
This week in Sialkot, near
Pakistan’s southern border with India, the streets were crammed with noisy
motorbikes and cargo trucks, and talk about the attack had died down. The Rajco
factory was closed and under guard, but dozens of other garment and small
manufacturing plants — a mainstay of Pakistan’s modest export economy — were
operating normally.
People from all walks of life
expressed horror and condemnation over the attack on Kumara, a bespectacled man
in his 50s who had managed the plant for more than a decade. Some had heard
conflicting versions of what sparked the workers to violence and were not sure
whether the foreign manager realized he was stripping sensitive Islamic sayings
off the walls.
“This was a very wrong thing, to
kill and burn a man in such a cruel way,” said Arshad Arif, 60, a retired
textile factory worker who was sitting in the sun with some friends. No matter
what alleged abuse triggered the workers’ violent wrath, he said, “It was
especially wrong if it was done in the name of God.”
Read more:
Hard-line Islamists take 6 Pakistani security personnel hostage
amid deadly clashes
More than three dozen dead, 100 injured after fire tears
through crowded ferry in Bangladesh
