November 2, 2018

TRUMP AND CHINA’S XI GIVE POSITIVE SIGNS OVER PHONE CALL BUT MARKETS GIVE UP EARLY GAINS

[Still, the two leaders will confront a long list of tough issues when they meet. Since Trump began imposing tariffs on Chinese imports several months ago, the United States has broadened its complaints about Chinese behavior to include its military buildup and the treatment of religious minorities in Xinjing.]



By David J. Lynch and Gerry Shih

President Trump chats with Chinese President Xi Jinping during a welcome ceremony 
at the Great Hall of the People in Beijing on Nov. 9, 2017. (Andy Wong/AP)
Stocks briefly rose on a report that President Trump has directed aides to draw up terms for a deal to resolve the escalating trade conflict with China, as he prepares to meet with Chinese President Xi Jinping at the G20 summit later this month in Buenos Aires.

The Dow Jones Industrial Average jumped nearly 200 points in early trading before surrendering those gains as analysts highlighted the obstacles to any deal between the two economic giants. In midday trading, the benchmark index was down more than 100 points.

Investors were cheered earlier by a Bloomberg News report that Trump has directed his aides to flesh out a possible bargain for the two leaders to consider when they meet. That report came hours after Trump said in a morning tweet that he had a “long and very good conversation” with Xi that included “a heavy emphasis on trade.”

The president added: “Those discussions are moving along nicely with meetings being scheduled at the G-20 in Argentina.”

Still, the two leaders will confront a long list of tough issues when they meet. Since Trump began imposing tariffs on Chinese imports several months ago, the United States has broadened its complaints about Chinese behavior to include its military buildup and the treatment of religious minorities in Xinjing.

Fresh trade data on Friday, meanwhile, showed that Trump has made no progress on his campaign to narrow the U.S. trade deficit. Through September, the United States imported $445.2 billion more goods and services than it sold abroad, up from a $404.4 billion deficit during the same period in 2017.

As importers rushed to beat the scheduled January 1 increase in U.S. tariffs on Chinese goods, the monthly goods deficit in September with China rose to $37.4 billion, up $3 billion from the previous month. Through the first nine months of the year, the United States has incurred a $301.4 billion deficit with China — up 10 percent from the same period last year.

On Thursday, the Justice Department unsealed the latest in a series of spying charges against Chinese companies and individuals.

The unusual slew of indictments are meant to be a stern warning to Beijing about pilfering U.S. tech secrets that, beyond the trade imbalance, illustrate Washington’s grievances about Chinese commercial behavior.


In a lengthy readout published by Chinese state media, Xi said he was “very happy” to talk to Trump and attached “great importance to the good relations with the president.”

But the Chinese assessment also betrayed frustration with the on-again, off-again nature of negotiations between Washington and Beijing. “China sees the US administration under Trump as inconsistent and untrustworthy,” wrote analysts at Trivium, an economic consultancy in Beijing.

The optimism that flared in the wake of Trump’s Thursday tweet and the subsequent Bloomberg report faded quickly.

Many analysts were skeptical that anything fundamental had changed in the U.S.-China standoff. There has been no indication, for instance, that Xi is willing to abandon the “Made-in-China 2025” program of state subsidies aimed at securing Chinese dominance of advanced technology industries.

“I think the chances of a near-term deal are low but not negligible. Given that the President reportedly has tasked some in the administration with developing the outlines of an arrangement and that he may want to bag a victory on China, anything is possible,” said Scott Kennedy, a China expert at the Center for Strategic and International Studies. “Hawks in the administration will argue against a deal for deal’s sake and the Chinese likely will stay true to form and not come through with the necessary concessions.”

The proximity of Trump’s sudden warming toward China and Tuesday’s congressional elections also drew comment. In recent days, as Republicans confront the possibility of losing their majority in the House of Representatives, Trump has unveiled a flurry of high-profile initiatives — including a promised middle-class tax cut and a military deployment to the southern border — designed to woo his voters.

“There is good reason to be skeptical of this kumbaya moment,” analyst Chris Krueger of the Cowen Washington Research Group wrote in a research note Friday.

China will host an import fair in Shanghai next week that Xi said will demonstrate Beijing’s commitment to “increase imports and expand openness,” according to the Chinese readout.

Xi is expected to make a major speech at the convention’s opening on Monday, where he could potentially discuss his vision for further market access reforms or the government’s role in steering industries — other areas in which Washington and U.S. businesses are demanding more Chinese concessions.

After months of fitful negotiations through intermediaries and lower-level officials, U.S. and Chinese officials hope that a meeting of the two presidents on the sidelines of the Buenos Aires summit will yield a breakthrough.

The months-long spat has weighed on worldwide markets at politically crucial junctures for both presidents: Trump is facing a key midterm test on Tuesday, while Xi has been navigating economic head winds and growing middle-class anxieties.

Larry Kudlow, Trump’s top economic adviser, said at a Washington Post Live event earlier Thursday that he wasn’t sure that trade would be discussed when the two presidents meet in Argentina but confirmed that the two men will sit down.

“The agenda is being discussed and worked on in both camps,” Kudlow said. “I think it will include trade, but I’m not 100 percent sure.”

It’s unclear how the progress in high-level talks will affect a new U.S. push to confront China on other thorny aspects of the trade relationship. Federal prosecutors have accused Chinese companies and individuals of spying in three cases in the past two months and pledged more to come on this week.

Hours after Trump’s tweet, Attorney General Jeff Sessions said the indictments are part of a new initiative to beef up the Justice Department’s “strategic priority of countering Chinese national security threats.”

The department unveiled an indictment on Thursday accusing Fujian Jinhua Integrated Circuit, a Chinese state-owned semiconductor company, of conspiring to steal secrets from the Idaho-based chipmaker Micron.

And earlier this week, prosecutors unveiled charges against Chinese intelligence officers who they said conspired to hack into aviation firms to obtain engine designs on behalf of China’s jetliner industry.


Shih reported from Hong Kong and Lynch reported from Washington


Read more: