June 19, 2018

NORTH KOREA’S KIM MAKES ANOTHER TRIP TO CHINA. THAT COMPLICATES THINGS FOR TRUMP.

[Kim’s visit to China this week will renew questions about what happens post-Singapore. Though Trump has taken great pains to cast last week’s summit as an unqualified success, the next steps are not clear.]


By Emily Rauhala

This image taken from China's CCTV on June 19, 2018, shows Chinese President 
Xi Jinping with his wife Peng Liyuan at right and North Korean leader Kim Jong Un 
with his wife Ri Sol-Ju at left during a welcome ceremony at the Great Hall of the
People in Beijing. (CCTV via AP Video) (Anonymous/
BEIJING — North Korean leader Kim Jong Un is in China. Again.

Kim arrived on Tuesday for his third visit to China in the span of three months, meeting with President Xi Jinping at the Great Hall of the People, in the heart of Beijing.

The visit comes a week after President Trump met with Kim in Singapore and a day after the United States confirmed it will cancel what Trump called “war games” with South Korea scheduled for August. News of Kim’s trip came just hours after Trump threatened China with tariffs on $200 billion worth of goods.

On Tuesday evening, Kim and his wife, Ri Sol Ju, were welcomed by Xi and his wife, Peng Liyuan. Pictures from the event show Kim and Xi shaking hands in front of a row of Chinese and North Korean flags — a visual echo of Kim and Trump’s much-photographed handshake in Singapore.

Xi reportedly praised the outcome of the Singapore summit, calling it an “important step toward the political solution of the Korean Peninsula nuclear issue,” according to the party-controlled press.

Though details are still scarce, the timing and staging of Kim’s trip sends a clear message about Beijing’s place at the center of East Asian diplomacy — and its power over Pyongyang. 

With U.S.-China trade ties on the rocks, Kim is well positioned to play both powers, talking sweet to Trump while pursuing a closer relationship with Xi.

“Although it seems there is a booming romance between Kim Jong Un and Trump, Kim understands the hierarchy. He knows that Xi is the Asian Godfather,” said Yanmei Xie, a China policy analyst at Gavekal Dragonomics, an economic research firm in Beijing.

“He is making a pragmatic calculation that China can provide economic assistance to integrate North Korea diplomatically and economically into Northeast Asia.”


Kim’s visit to China this week will renew questions about what happens post-Singapore. Though Trump has taken great pains to cast last week’s summit as an unqualified success, the next steps are not clear.

What has come out of the summit, so far, seems like a version of China’s “dual suspension” strategy — a plan that asks North Korea to suspend nuclear testing in return for a suspension of U.S. military exercises.

With testing halted, for now, and August’s war games off, China may be willing to cut North Korea some slack.

In Beijing, Kim is likely to ask Xi to ease up on economic sanctions — something the United States strongly opposes.

Last week, Secretary of State Mike Pompeo said in Beijing at a news conference with Foreign Minister Wang Yi that China “acknowledged that the sanctions regime that is in place today will remain in place until such time as that denuclearization is in fact complete.”

But the problem is that there is no consensus on what “denuclearization” means.


The United States wants North Korea to abandon the nuclear weapons program that it took years to build — an outcome experts see as extremely unlikely.

“There is a regional effort, a sort of Northeast Asia coalition of make-believe, to maintain the fiction that the North Korea will de-nuke as long as Americans keep talking to it,” Xie said.

China is less focused on getting Kim to give away his weapons than on getting him to fall into line. It may eventually use trade and investment to keep him onside, experts said.

With North Korea still struggling under United Nations sanctions, “China’s political and economic support is still highly important,” said Zhao Tong, a North Korea expert at the Carnegie-Tsinghua Center for Global Policy in Beijing.

The question now, Zhao said, is “how can China help North Korea develop its economy?”

China can also help Kim normalize North Korea’s diplomatic status. That starts with treating him less like a rogue dictator and more like a visiting statesman — a progression that can be seen in his recent visits.

On Kim’s first visit as leader, in March, he arrived unannounced aboard an armored train. Beijing did not disclose his presence, or publish photos, until he left.

He met Xi a second time in May in the Chinese port city of Dalian. Photographs of the two leaders strolling and chatting by the seaside were not released until Kim was on his way home.

On Tuesday morning, there were reports of tight security around Beijing. Not long after, Chinese state media confirmed that Kim would be in town.

Then that evening, Chinese media released photographs of Kim meeting Xi at the Great Hall of the People, where he often greets visiting dignitaries and heads of state — the first time that photos of Kim in China have been released while a visit was in progress.

A South Korea Unification Ministry official said Tuesday that officials were closely monitoring any possible statements from Kim and the Chinese leadership.

The White House will no doubt be watching, too.