November 18, 2016

INDIA OFFERS SOME RELIEF TO CHAOS IT CREATED WITH CURRENCY BAN

[Mr. Modi has begun to come in for criticism, after being afforded a remarkable grace period. Politicians clashed over the move, and Parliament was adjourned amid raucous debates over the plan, which was intended to drain unaccounted cash, so-called black money, from the economy to cut down on rampant corruption and tax avoidance.]


By Nida Nazar

Men waited to exchange currency at a bank in Amritsar, India, on Thursday.
Prime Minister Narendra Modi announced on Nov. 8 that India’s highest-value 
bills, the 1,000 and 500 rupee notes, worth about $15 and $7.50, would cease 
being legal tender. Credit Narinder Nanu/Agence France-Presse — Getty Images
NEW DELHI — As the chaos surrounding Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s ban on high-currency bills entered its ninth day, the government moved Thursday to address some of the problems amid signs of growing impatience with the slapdash way the policy seems to have been carried out.

Since the move was announced, retail commerce has slowed, farmers who deal almost exclusively in cash have had no buyers and people have waited in long lines at banks and ATMs in hopes of getting a paltry amount of the new notes the government is in the process of printing.

To deal with the continuing liquidity crunch, the government on Thursday cut the exchange limit to 2,000 rupees, or about $30, from 4,500 rupees, or about $66, effective Friday, so that the cash would be more widely distributed. This week, banks began using indelible ink to mark fingers of people who had exchanged old notes to weed out repeated exchanges.

In a nod to the wedding season here, the government said Thursday that families celebrating a marriage could withdraw 250,000 rupees, or about $3,700, from their bank accounts for the event.

Farmers gained some relief, with permission to withdraw 25,000 rupees a week against their crop loans, the government said. Traders were allowed withdrawals of 50,000 rupees a week, allowing them to pay for labor and produce at wholesale markets.

The government was also racing to calibrate ATMs with the newly issued 2,000 rupee notes and smaller currency.

Mr. Modi has begun to come in for criticism, after being afforded a remarkable grace period. Politicians clashed over the move, and Parliament was adjourned amid raucous debates over the plan, which was intended to drain unaccounted cash, so-called black money, from the economy to cut down on rampant corruption and tax avoidance.

Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal of Delhi and Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee of West Bengal joined forces in opposition to the policy on Thursday, attending a rally against the decision in New Delhi and demanding that it be rolled back in three days.

In a televised interview, Finance Minister Arun Jaitley expressed regret over the inconvenience but said it was unavoidable because “we have to withdraw currency which is used for generating black money.”

Mr. Modi announced on Nov. 8 that India’s highest-value bills, the 1,000 and 500 rupee notes, worth about $15 and $7.50, would cease being legal tender the next morning. The bills represent more than 80 percent of the currency in the country. The old currency could be exchanged for new bills, but those were in short supply and no replacement bills had been printed to avoid tipping off anyone about the plan.

Officials warned that while they were doing what they could, the currency shortage was not going to disappear overnight.

“Please remember this dislocation is not going to get over in the 50 days the prime minister has mentioned,” Arun Shourie, a former cabinet minister, said Thursday evening on NDTV, an Indian news channel, adding that experts had estimated the full adjustment could take months.

“The scale of this event is so unprecedented that we are all struggling to see where the chips will fall,” Pratap Bhanu Mehta, the president of the Centre for Policy Research, wrote in The Indian Express. “Just as a matter of political analysis, the sheer audacity of this move is breathtaking.”

Follow Nida Najar on Twitter @nidanajar.

Hari Kumar contributed reporting.

Ms. Saunders said the Tibetans were mostly from Kham and Amdo, Tibetan regions now ruled by China, and were on a pilgrimage to sacred sites in Nepal and India. It is likely that they planned to go in January to an important Buddhist ceremony, the Kalachakra teaching, in Bodh Gaya, an Indian city, she said.

By Edward Wong
Forty-one Tibetans who were detained by the Nepalese police while they were on a bus bound for India have been released to a Nepalese human rights group, an advocate for Tibetan rights said Friday.

The advocate, Kate Saunders, of the International Campaign for Tibet, said early Friday in London that the human rights group, the Human Rights Organization of Nepal, and other contacts in Kathmandu, Nepal’s capital, had told her that immigration officials and the police had allowed all the Tibetans to be released.

Ms. Saunders said the Tibetans were mostly from Kham and Amdo, Tibetan regions now ruled by China, and were on a pilgrimage to sacred sites in Nepal and India. It is likely that they planned to go in January to an important Buddhist ceremony, the Kalachakra teaching, in Bodh Gaya, an Indian city, she said.

It is unclear what those Tibetans will do now. They could end up at the Kathmandu transit center of the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees. From there, many Tibetans make their way to India, against China’s wishes. Ms. Saunders said the Tibetans were in a “very precarious situation.”

The Human Rights Organization of Nepal did not respond to an email asking for an update on the situation of the Tibetans.

The Dalai Lama, the spiritual leader of the Tibetans, is expected to teach at the Kalachakra gathering from Jan. 3 to Jan. 14. He offers this teaching regularly at different places, and many Tibetans try to make their way to Bodh Gaya, the site where the Buddha attained enlightenment, when the Dalai Lama travels there from his home in northern India to teach.

In 2012, Chinese security officials detained hundreds of Tibetans after they returned from the Kalachakra in Bodh Gaya. Many of them were released later. The Chinese government opposes the Dalai Lama and calls him a “splittist,” but Tibetans remain devoted to him, and many try to travel to India to see him.

Since a widespread uprising across Tibetan regions in 2008, the Chinese government has increased its security presence on the Tibet-Nepal border and has prevented many Tibetans from leaving. The number of Tibetans making their way to Nepal has plummeted. China is also exercising greater influence over Nepal, and Tibetans in Nepal complain of more detentions there and a ban on anti-China protests.

Ms. Saunders said Chinese officials were making great efforts to prevent Tibetans from traveling to Bodh Gaya this year for the Dalai Lama’s teaching.

“What we know is that the Chinese authorities have tightened controls on Tibetans, in some areas going from house to house to confiscate people’s passports,” she said.

“In the last few weeks, government officials have confiscated passports in the Tibetan areas of Qinghai and Gansu, and according to some sources, also in Sichuan and the Tibet Autonomous Region,” she added. “Some Tibetans who have already arrived in Nepal and India for pilgrimage and for attending the religious ceremony in Bodh Gaya have already been ordered to return, and their families pressured by the authorities.”

“So no doubt for this group of 41, things will be very difficult,” she said, “particularly given that they will now be on the radar of the Chinese authorities in Nepal, given the nature of the relationship between the two governments.”

Follow Edward Wong on Twitter @comradewong.