[The
cooperation reflects a notable thaw in ties after the anger in 2013 over
American surveillance of Brazil ’s political leaders by the National Security
Agency. And the shift came into sharp relief last month, when Brazilian
investigators revealed that the F.B.I. had helped them identify and track
several of the 10 men arrested on suspicion of planning attacks for a Brazilian
Islamist militant group called the Defenders of Shariah.]
By Simon Romero and Michael S. Schmidt
Brazilian soldiers guarded the Olympic beach volleyball arena
in
The New York Times
|
Despite
its notorious battles with violent crime, Brazil has largely been spared the kind of brazen
terrorist attacks that have rattled much of the world in recent years, with
Brazilian officials long playing down the nation’s vulnerability to homegrown
extremism.
But
jihadists are calling for mayhem at the Olympics, building on a wave of
killings in Europe , the United States and elsewhere over the last year, including
the massacre of 130 people in Paris and “lone wolf” attacks inspired by the
Islamic State, that has raised broad fears about Brazil ’s security preparations for the Games.
American
officials have been training Brazilian antiterrorism units on chemical and
biological attacks. They are helping to identify soft targets like restaurants,
night clubs and shopping malls that are away from well-guarded Olympic sites. And
they have been working for many months to train Brazilian law enforcement and
military personnel at large American sporting events, including the Super Bowl
in February.
The
cooperation reflects a notable thaw in ties after the anger in 2013 over
American surveillance of Brazil ’s political leaders by the National Security
Agency. And the shift came into sharp relief last month, when Brazilian
investigators revealed that the F.B.I. had helped them identify and track
several of the 10 men arrested on suspicion of planning attacks for a Brazilian
Islamist militant group called the Defenders of Shariah.
“The
Americans are playing a key role in homing in on areas that we need to examine,”
said Rafael Brum Miron, a prosecutor in the southern city of Curitiba . “I don’t know how the F.B.I. got their
intelligence, but it turned out to be a very valuable lead.”
Fears
of terrorism are common before any Olympics. But the frequency of recent
attacks around the world — and Brazil ’s relative inexperience in grappling with
terrorism — have led to a sense of urgency in Rio .
For
weeks, the Islamic State has been translating its core propaganda into
Portuguese and advertising that it needs Portuguese speakers, in what analysts
fear is an attempt to recruit and create a network in Brazil to strike around the Olympics.
Jihadist
outlets have been increasing calls for attacks. On July 19, a channel titled
“Inspire the Believers!” on Telegram, an encrypted phone app, advised that
“Lone Wolf from anywhere in the world can move to Brazil now. Visas and tickets and travel to Brazil will be very easy to get in sha Allah.”
The
channel then went on to offer 17 suggestions for attacks around the Olympics, mentioning
American, British, French and Israeli visitors as targets. It noted that
attackers could drop “poisons or medicines” into food and drinks, or use “toy
drones with small explosives,” according to SITE Intelligence Group, which monitors jihadist
communications channels.
The
same channel had already suggested taking inspiration from the 1972 massacre of
Israeli athletes during the Munich Olympics.
Such
messages come on the heels of the founding of a new group in Brazil , claiming to be made up of Brazilians, that
pledged allegiance to the Islamic State’s leader, Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi.
About
a year and a half ago, the State Department’s Bureau of Diplomatic Security, which
has taken the lead in protecting American athletes abroad, expanded its
footprint in Rio to begin preparing for the Games. The
Brazilians have managed big international sporting events before, including the
2014 World Cup. Still, what the bureau initially found was a bit troubling, as
it quickly identified several soft spots in Brazil ’s security, according to senior American
officials.
The
Brazilians appeared to have little training in how to deal with attacks
involving biological or radiological materials. Brazilian counterterrorism
operations also seemed to lack enough agents, while security experts argued
that legislation to detain and prosecute suspects on terrorism charges lacked
teeth.
The
United
States
offered training to the Brazilians, who were more open to American help than
from recent Olympic hosts like Russia and China . Dozens of Brazilian officials, law
enforcement officers and military personnel flew to the United States . Several attended events like the Super Bowl
and the United States Open golf tournament to observe how the United States manages security at such high-profile
contests.
Still,
some American officials worried that Brazil was not taking the threat seriously enough. Trying
to avoid taking sides in foreign conflicts, including those in the Middle East , has been a pillar of Brazilian foreign
policy. Some political leaders here contend that doing so could make Brazil a target for Islamist militant groups.
But
the assessment of Brazil ’s vulnerability began to change around the
end of last year, American officials and Brazilian security analysts said, as
the Islamic State continued to show that it could carry out and inspire attacks
in different parts of the world.
“The
changing nature of attacks around the world and the realization that Brazil is vulnerable with the proximity of the
Olympics have been pushing the government to rethink its approach,” said Marcos
Ferreira, a scholar at the Federal University of Paraíba who focuses on
terrorism in South America .
In
March, President Dilma Rousseff signed antiterrorism legislation that enhanced
the government’s authority to arrest and jail people suspected of planning
attacks. Human rights groups criticized the law as being too broad, but Ms. Rousseff,
a leftist who was imprisoned as a youth over her involvement in a guerrilla
group resisting the military dictatorship, signed the law despite fears that it
could be used to infringe on civil liberties.
“There
is increasing awareness in Brazil of the threat of terrorism, and we are
pleased that Brazil passed a new counterterrorism law in March,”
said Liliana Ayalde, the American ambassador to Brazil . “The legislation has opened up new channels
of cooperation between our two governments.”
The
passage of the law — along with the increased intelligence sharing between
Brazilian and American officials — unfolded here at a time of political
upheaval. Ms. Rousseff, who is now facing an impeachment trial, was trying to
fend off opponents’ attempts to topple her. Her vice president, Michel Temer, emerged
victorious in the power struggle. As interim president, he is now waiting to
see if the Senate definitively ousts Ms. Rousseff in an impeachment trial on
charges of budgetary manipulation.
But
the political turmoil did not seem to affect Brazil ’s preparations for threats around the
Olympics. Officials from both countries who had been interacting with one
another said they continued to do so despite the changes in the upper echelons
of government.
The
United
States
has tried to keep a low profile around its counterterrorism operations for the
Olympics to avoid being seen as meddling in a country that was rattled by the
spy scandal, in which the N.S.A. monitored Brazil ’s top leaders.
But
the cooperation between the two countries became ever more apparent last month
when the Brazilian authorities announced that they had arrested the 10 men from
the Defenders of Shariah. The suspects, all Brazilian citizens, have profiles
similar to those of dozens who have been arrested in the United States .
But
the arrests set off a debate over whether Brazil ’s government had overreached in detaining
the men, who are being held at a maximum-security prison.
“They
may be sympathizers, but they are not terrorists,” said Ahmad al-Khatib, 49, a
Sunni Muslim leader in São Paulo who founded an outreach group that teaches Arabic and assists
Syrian refugees. Two of the suspects, Antonio Andrade dos Santos and Vitor Barbosa Magalhães, both of whom
recently converted to Islam, worked at Mr. Khatib’s organization.
“I
am certain that they never had the intention of doing terrorism in Brazil.” he
said.
The
federal judge overseeing the case questioned whether the suspects could even be
called terrorists.
Rukmini
Callimachi contributed reporting from Stuttgart , Germany .