[The scandal is just the latest crisis to shake public faith in China ’s food and medicine supplies, but it is the first big scare under Mr. Xi, who had vowed to be different. He had come into office promising to “make protecting the people’s right to health a priority.”]
By Chris Buckley
Officials with the China Food
and Drug Administration checking vaccines last
month at a clinic in Rong’an
County, in the southern region of Guangxi.
Credit Tan Kaixing/European
Pressphoto Agency
|
HEZE,
China — First the news rippled across China that millions of compromised vaccines had
been given to children around the country. Then came grim rumors and angry
complaints from parents that the government had kept them in the dark about the
risks since last year.
Now,
the country’s immunization program faces a backlash of public distrust that
critics say has been magnified by the government’s ingrained secrecy.
Song
Zhendong, like many parents here, said he was reluctant to risk further
vaccinations for his child, a 10-month-old boy he cradled in his arms.
“If
he can avoid them in the future, we will not get them,” said Mr. Song, a
businessman. “Why didn’t we learn about this sooner? If there’s a problem with
vaccines for our kids, we should be told as soon as the police knew. Aren’t our
children the future of the nation?”
The
faulty vaccines have become the latest lightning rod for widespread, often
visceral distrust of China’s medical system, as well as a rebuff to what many
Chinese critics see as President Xi Jinping’s bulldozing, top-down rule.
The
scandal is just the latest crisis to shake public faith in China ’s food and medicine supplies, but it is the
first big scare under Mr. Xi, who had vowed to be different. He had come into
office promising to “make protecting the people’s right to health a priority.”
“If
our party can’t even handle food safety properly while governing China, and
this keeps up, some will wonder whether we’re up to the job,” Mr. Xisaid in 2013,
the year he became president.
About
two million improperly stored vaccines had been sold around the country from an
overheated, dilapidated storeroom. The main suspect in the case is a hospital
pharmacist from Heze who had been convicted of trading in illegal vaccines in 2009
and was doing it again two years later.
Many
parents said they were especially alarmed that nearly a year had elapsed from
the time the police uncovered the illicit trade and the time the public first
learned about it in February.
“Withholding
information doesn’t maintain public credibility,” said Li Shuqing, a lawyer in Jinan , the capital of Shandong Province , who is one of about 90 attorneys who have
volunteered to represent possible victims in the case. “In the end, it makes
people more distrustful.”
To
many here, the combination of lax regulation and the secrecy surrounding a
potential public health crisis seems like déjà vu.
In
the SARS crisis of 2003, 349 people died across mainland China and hundreds more died elsewhere after
officials hid the extent of its spread. In a scandal that came to light in 2008,
at least six children died and 300,000 fell ill with kidney stones and other
problems from infant formulaadulterated with melamine, an industrial chemical.
“The
customers worry about fake milk powder, fake medicine, fake vaccines, fake
everything,” said Ma Guohui, the owner of a shop on the rural fringe of Heze
that sells baby products. “This is certainly going to affect people’s thinking.
My boy got all his vaccination shots. If he were born now, I’d worry.”
Despite
such fears, the tainted vaccines are more likely to be ineffective than harmful.
The
World Health Organization has said that outdated or poorly stored vaccines
rarely if ever trigger illness or toxic reactions. Chinese government
investigators said last week that they had not found any cases of adverse
reactions or spikes in infections linked to ineffective vaccines.
The
greater danger may be more insidious. The erosion of public trust could damage China ’s successful immunization program, which has
been credited with dramatic declines in measles and other communicable diseases.
“Confidence
is easy to shake, and that’s happened across the world and has happened here,”
said Lance Rodewald, a doctor with the World Health Organization’s immunization
program in Beijing . “We hear through social media that parents
are worried, and we know that when they’re worried, there’s a very good chance
that they may think it’s safer not to vaccinate than to vaccinate. That’s when
trouble can start.”
After
unfounded reports of deaths caused by a hepatitis B vaccine in 2013, such
vaccinations across 10 provinces fell by 30 percent in the days afterward, and
the administration of other mandatory vaccines fell by 15 percent, according to
Chinese health officials.
The
illicit vaccines in the current case were not part of China ’s compulsory, state-financed vaccination
program, which inoculates children against illnesses such as polio and measles
at no charge.
The
illegal trade dealt in so-called second-tier vaccines — including those for
rabies, influenza and hepatitis B — which patients pay for from their own pockets.
The
pharmacist named in the investigation, Pang Hongwei, bought cheap vaccines from
drug companies and traders — apparently batches close to their expiration dates
— and sold them in 23 provinces and cities, especially in rural eastern and
central China, according to drug safety investigators.
She
began the business in 2011, just two years after she had been convicted on
charges of illegally trading in vaccines and sentenced to three years in prison,
which was reduced to five years’ probation. Officials have not explained how
she was able to avoid prison and resume her business.
Ms.
Pang, in her late 40s, and her daughter, who has been identified only by her
surname, Sun, kept the vaccines in a rented storeroom of a disused factory in Jinan . The storeroom lacked refrigeration, which
may have damaged the vaccines’ potency. The police have detained them but not
announced specific charges, and neither suspect has had a chance to respond
publicly to the accusations.
Lax
regulation in the second-tier commercial system allowed Ms. Pang’s business to
grow, several medical experts said. Local government medical agencies and
clinics were able to increase their profits by turning to cheap, illegal
suppliers, People’s Daily, the official party paper, reported Tuesday.
Police
investigators discovered Ms. Pang’s storehouse last April, but word did not get
out to the public until a Shandong news website reported on the case in February of this year. Most
Chinese had still heard nothing about it until another website, The Paper, published
a report that drew national attention a month later.
It
was the government’s intolerance of public criticism, critics said, that kept
the scandal under wraps, a delay that now makes it harder to track those who
received the suspect injections.
“We’ve
seen with these problem vaccines that without the right to know, without press
freedom, the public’s right to health can’t be assured,” said Wang Shengsheng, who
is one of the lawyers pressing the government for more answers and redress over
the case.
In
the last few weeks, official reticence has been supplanted by daily
announcements of arrests, checks and assurances as the central government has
scrambled to dampen public anger and alarm.
Premier
Li Keqiang ordered central ministries and agencies in March to investigate what
had gone wrong.
Last
week, the investigators reported that 202 people had been detained over the
scandal, and 357 officials dismissed, demoted or otherwise punished. Health and
drug officials promised to tighten vaccine purchase rules to stamp out under-the-counter
trade.
“How
could this trafficking in vaccines outside the rules spread to so many places
and go on for so long?” Mr. Li said, according to an official account. Without
decisive action, he said, “ordinary people will vote with their feet and go and
buy the products they trust.”
Mr.
Xi has so far not publicly commented on the scandal.
Dr.
Rodewald, the World Health Organization expert, said the proposed changes were
promising and would mean clinics would not have to rely on selling patient-paid
vaccines for their upkeep.
Xu
Huijin, a doctor in Heze, said that the concern over the scandal — and
unfounded rumors of deaths — had depressed the number of parents bringing
children to her clinic for inoculations.
“This
was badly handled,” she said. “There was a lack of coordination, not enough
information. We should have found out about this long ago. Doctors are taught
to tell patients the full facts.”
Follow
Chris Buckley on Twitter @ChuBailiang.
Adam
Wu contributed research from Beijing .