[So, why would even the Madhesis want the whole of the Tarai to be a provincial strip in the plains only? Why would New Delhi also push that? A plausible answer was provided recently by Indian columnist Ananda Swarup Verma who wrote that India could be ‘trying to turn Nepal into another Jaffna’. The Tamil separatist conflict in northern Sri Lanka sucked India into a bloody and unwinnable war that New Delhi barely extricated itself from.]
By Bihari Krishna Shrestha
|The author's interface with Sagaramatha TV in Kathmandu on |
the Devastating April-May Earthquake Video >>
The Nepali language media last week was rife with reports that Indian officials told Foreign Minister Kamal Thapa during his recent visit to New Delhi that the bottom line for ending the blockade was that the word ‘secular’ should be removed from the preamble of the newly-adopted constitution and the whole of the Tarai should be one province.
While the advantage of
being declared Hindu Rastra once again for
the BJP’s domestic audience is understandable in the meantime, what is puzzling is the
purported insistence on the whole of the Tarai delineated as a single province.
Incidentally, the same demand was raised by the Loktantrik Madheshi Morcha back
in 2007 during the first Madhes Movement. The similarity between that
demand then and the Indian conditionality now, if true, is intriguing. Nepal
That proposal makes absolutely no sense from whichever angle you look at it. The Tarai is a narrow strip of land some 30km wide running 800km east-west, how can it ever be self-governing? What do the people of Jhapa have in common with those in Kanchanpur? They are much closer to their cousins in Ilam and Panchthar. Secondly, the Tarai is ethnically diverse with people of Madhes and Pahad background more or less equally represented at close to 40 percent each.
|Credit: Nepali Times|
There are other even more compelling reasons why a separate Tarai province would be potentially disastrous for its inhabitants. The massive extraction of groundwater across the border in the Indian plains has meant that the water table in the Tarai is receding fast.
While only a few decades ago, a tubewell 6m deep would have water, it now needs to be at least 50m deep. The worse is yet to come. The only possible sources of water for the Tarai for drinking, irrigation and industrial development will be the rivers and streams flowing down from the northern mountains.
Integrating the Tarai with the mountains makes common sense also from the development perspective. The West Seti project will submerge 2000 ha of land and displace 16,000 people in the four hill districts of Doti, Dadeldhura, Bajhang and Baitadi, but would irrigate 360,000 ha of farmlands in the three Tharu heartland districts of Bardia, Kailali and Kanchanpur, generate 750 MW of electricity to be used mostly in the factories of the Tarai yielding an annual revenue of Rs 15 billion that could be used for the overall development of the country including the districts upstream.
So, why would even the Madhesis want the whole of the Tarai to be a provincial strip in the plains only? Why would
also push that? A plausible answer was
provided recently by Indian columnist Ananda Swarup Verma who wrote that New Delhi could be ‘trying to turn India into another Nepal ’. The Tamil separatist conflict in northern Jaffna sucked
Sri Lanka into a bloody and unwinnable war that India barely extricated itself from. New Delhi
hasn’t been as blatant in the Nepal Tarai
as it had in northern India , but we must learn from Sri Lanka ’s mistakes to protect India ’s national integrity. While, with all the behind-the-scene
activities going on and the growing criticism within Nepal of the Modi government for blockading India the siege could come to an early end. Or,
it may not. Nepal
Either way, the
government would do well to use this
opportunity to bolster political and trade ties with Nepal . Not to thumb our noses at China , but to restore balance in our bilateral
ties with the northern and southern neighbours. This would raise hackles in India , but India will realise that it was its folly that pushed New Delhi to the north. Nepal
The heading Zaffnaization of Nepal's Madesh was interesting and read it through.
It is preposterous in the part of that Indian official who even talked of Jaffanaization of Nepal's Madhesh, if at all he did. It is in the verge of being stupid, if I may say so, because India has learnt its lessons in Sri Lanka well and will not resort to such adventurism. It will be diplomatic Hara-kiri. And India is not so stupid to do so.
I therefore request all the Nepalese media and leaders of Nepal who are devoting considerable time to shape India-Nepal future relation to be more careful in their utterances and arouse the negative sentiments in the minds of people in both countries.
Col. Shiv Om Rana, PhD
Mob +9199999 078 seven zero
Twitter handle : @happyshiv
My Blogs are here >>
For more, please click >>