[In delegating authority, Mr.
Baghdadi has drawn lessons from the fates of other militant groups, including
that of a branch in Yemen called Al Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula, whose
leaders have been whittled away by repeated American drone strikes over the
years, said a Western diplomat who monitors the group.]
a
A New Offensive Against
The Iraqi government announced
on Monday that it was beginning
a major military operation to
retake
|
WASHINGTON — The Islamic State’s
reclusive leader has empowered his inner circle of deputies as well as regional
commanders in Syria and Iraq with wide-ranging authority, a plan to ensure that
if he or other top figures are killed, the organization will quickly adapt and
continue fighting, American and Iraqi intelligence officials say.
The officials say the leader, Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi,
delegates authority to his cabinet, or shura council, which includes ministers
of war, finance, religious affairs and others.
The Islamic State’s leadership under Mr. Baghdadi has drawn
mainly from two pools: veterans of Al
Qaeda in Iraq who
survived the insurgency against American forces with battle-tested militant
skills, and former Baathist officers under Saddam Hussein with expertise in
organization, intelligence and internal security. It is the merger of these two
skill sets that has made the organization such a potent force, the officials
say.
But
equally important to the group’s flexibility has been the power given to
Islamic State military commanders, who receive general operating guidelines but
have significant autonomy to run their own operations in Iraq and Syria,
according to American and Kurdish officials. This means that fighters have
limited information about the inner workings of the Islamic State to give up if
captured, and that local commanders can be killed and replaced without
disrupting the wider organization. Within this hierarchy, Iraqis still hold the
top positions, while Tunisians and Saudis hold many religious posts.
In delegating authority, Mr. Baghdadi has drawn lessons from the
fates of other militant groups, including that of a branch in Yemen called Al Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula, whose
leaders have been whittled away by repeated American drone strikes over the
years, said a Western diplomat who monitors the group.
“ISIS has learned from that and has
formed a structure that can survive the losses of leaders by giving midlevel
commanders a degree of autonomy,” the diplomat said. In that structure, the
overall operation would not be immediately affected if Mr. Baghdadi were
wounded or killed, he said.
The Islamic State has also studied revelations from Edward J.
Snowden, the former National Security Agency contractor, about how the United States gathers information on
militants. A main result is that group’s top leaders now use couriers or
encrypted channels that Western analysts cannot crack to communicate,
intelligence and military officials said.
The two top leaders after Mr.
Baghdadi appear to be Abu Alaa al-Afri, a former top deputy to Abu Musab
al-Zarqawi, the former militant leader in Iraq; and Fadel al-Hayali, known as
Abu Muslim al-Turkmani, a former Iraqi Special Forces officer from the town of
Tal Afar, near Mosul, although there have been unconfirmed Iraqi reports that
both men were killed in airstrikes in recent months. It is unclear who would
replace Mr. Baghdadi as the self-declared caliph if he died, a Kurdish official
said. But the official said it could not be Mr. Afri, assuming he is alive,
because he is an ethnic Turkmen, and the caliph must be an Arab from the
Quraysh tribe of the Prophet Muhammad, as Mr. Baghdadi claims to be.
The United States is actively hunting Mr.
Baghdadi — rumors that he was killed or injured this year have been dispelled.
Defense Secretary Ashton B. Carter told reporters this month that if the
opportunity for a strike against Mr. Baghdadi presented itself, “we would
certainly take it.”
Despite the trove of information uncovered in May, American
intelligence and counterterrorism officials say there are still large gaps in
what they know about how the Islamic State’s leadership operates and how it
interacts with a growing number of affiliates and other followers from Nigeria
to Afghanistan. “It is going to just take some time to connect everything
together,” said a senior Defense Department official who, like nearly a dozen
other officials interviewed here and in Iraq , agreed to discuss confidential
intelligence reports only on the condition of anonymity.
The Islamic State’s strict secrecy, which has allowed its
leadership to remain so mysterious, has led to some differences among American
and other Western analysts on the degree to which Mr. Baghdadi is in charge and
whether the main power in the organization rests with his allies, including
several of the former Baathist officers.
A senior Kurdish security official in northern Iraq and several American officials
said that Mr. Baghdadi was very much the top leader and that he was involved in
issuing orders across the group’s territories. “While many other group leaders
also oversee and manage operations, Baghdadi asserts his role through providing
guidance and holding meetings with leadership,” said a senior United States military official with access
to classified briefings on the Islamic State.
But
other analysts said that Mr. Baghdadi’s religious credibility was more
significant than any operational prowess.
“Baghdadi is to a certain extent a religious figurehead designed
to grant an aura of religious legitimacy and respectability to the group’s
operations, while the real power brokers are a core of former military and
intelligence officials,” said Matthew Henman, managing editor of IHS Jane’s Terrorism and Insurgency Center.
The Islamic State maintains tight
control over the flow of information about it, with a list of rules about what
its fighters may and may not mention, analysts said. As such, much of the
information made public has come from the group itself and conveys the image
that it wishes to project.
Kurdish
commanders fighting the Islamic State on the ground say that certain groups of
foreign fighters appear to move like shock troops around territory controlled by the
group.
Before a major Islamic State offensive on the city of Kirkuk early this year, the Kurds
began getting reports that a Russian commander had come there with his own
group of fighters, said Polad Talabani, the head of the counterterrorism unit
of the Kurdistan regional government.
To fuel its war effort, the Islamic State relies heavily on
explosives and has set up factories to provide them to fighters. Improvised
explosive devices, or I.E.D.s, defused by Mr. Talabani’s men were welded metal
squares the size of briefcases, with sturdy handles to make them easy to carry
and distribute.
Another commander displayed cellphone fuses used to remotely
detonate bombs. On each one was a sticker with instructions printed in Arabic
on how to use it, including which ringtone to choose.
“Do not use Korek SIM cards,” the instructions read,
using the name of a Kurdish-owned wireless company. The warning appears to be a
response to the possibility that Kurdish officials could shut down the cell
towers during a battle so the Islamic State could not detonate its bombs.
“We are not there to follow up,” the military official said. “We
are not there to check on damage that is caused by strikes, and so we have to
make our best assessment by viewing the footage.”
When asked if the Islamic State was run from the top down or if
local commanders did their own thing, he said, “I’m not sure if we have clarity
on that either way.”
Eric
Schmitt reported from Washington, and Ben Hubbard from Erbil ,
Iraq .