[Using ideological language reminiscent of the Cold War,
Chinese officials have voiced conspiracy theories with relish, accusing
foreigners, their companies, national agencies and nongovernmental
organizations of plotting to weaken or overthrow the party. Chinese
institutions with ties to Western entities, no matter how benign, have also
come under attack. Meanwhile, state-run newspapers have taken to blaming
“hostile foreign forces” for any major disturbance, whether it is ethnic
violence in western China or student-led pro-democracy demonstrations in Hong Kong .]
Zhou Xiaoping's blog has been hailed by propaganda officials but widely mocked
by scholars in
|
BEIJING — Even as
his government was making red-carpet plans to host President Obama this week, the
Chinese president, Xi Jinping,
praised a young blogger whose writing is best known here for its anti-American
vitriol.
In one widely circulated essay published by state news outlets titled
“Nine Knockout Blows in America ’s Cold War Against China,” the blogger, Zhou Xiaoping,
argued that American culture was “eroding the moral foundation and
self-confidence of the Chinese people.” He compared unfavorable American news
coverage of China to Hitler’s treatment of the Jews. In another essay, he
said the West had “slaughtered and robbed” China and other civilizations since the 17th century, and was
now “brainwashing” it.
Mr. Xi,
speaking at a forum last month aimed at tightening political control of the
arts, said the blogger exhibited “positive energy.”
His
embrace of Mr. Zhou, who has been hailed by propaganda officials but widely
mocked by scholars here, is just the latest sign of rising anti-Western
sentiment, bordering on xenophobia, that has emanated from the highest levels
of the Communist Party and sent a chill through Chinese civil society and
academia.
The
vilification of foreigners as enemies of China has been a staple of propaganda
by the Communist Party since before its rise to power, and analysts say the
leadership tends to ramp up such rhetoric when it feels under pressure at home.
“Historically, during every period with many deep
conflicts within the country, there has been a surge of anti-foreign sentiments
from the party,” said Zhang Lifan, a historian, pointing to Mao Zedong’s
disastrous Cultural Revolution as an example. At the moment, he said, “the
political establishment needs the public to turn their rage toward foreign
countries” because anger over the widening gap between rich and poor in China has reached “crisis levels.”
But
unlike earlier campaigns targeting the West, the current wave of nationalism
comes as China is ascendant. Mr. Xi presides over a country that is on
the verge of overtaking the United States as the world’s largest economy and that enjoys influence
around the world, especially in Asia , where it has sought to expand its territorial
footprint.
In speeches, Mr. Xi has openly called on other nations to
push back against the United States on specific issues. In July, for example, he told Brazil ’s National Congress that developing nations must
“challenge U.S. hegemony on the Internet.” Two months earlier, Mr. Xi suggested at a conference in Shanghai that the United States should cede power in Asia ,
saying, “It is for the people of Asia to run the affairs of Asia .”
The surge in anti-Americanism extends beyond speeches.
Over the summer, for example, the Chinese government began a security review of foreign NGOs operating in China , as well as Chinese NGOs that receive foreign support,
scrutinizing their finances and freezing bank accounts. A strident, 100-minute anti-American propaganda film made by the People’s Liberation Army
last year laid out the case that American NGOs were out to undermine the party.
(It used the martial theme music from the HBO series “Game of Thrones.”)
In Guangdong , the southern province adjacent to Hong Kong
that has long been more open to foreign influence and investment, officials
have considered shutting down Chinese NGOs that depend primarily on foreign
funds, the state-run newspaper Global
Times reported last
week.
Wang
Jiangsong, a professor of labor relations at the China Institute of Industrial
Relations, was quoted in the newspaper saying that the authorities had secretly
tracked transfers of overseas money to the Chinese organizations, and were
worried that “some NGOs would be manipulated by overseas forces and conduct
activities that may endanger national security and undermine social stability.”
The campaign has reached into academia as well. An
employee of an American organization that promotes dialogue among scholars said
some Chinese professors who work on international relations are no longer
writing or saying anything in public that casts the United States in a positive light, for fear of being accused of being
a spy. The employee, who spoke on condition of anonymity so as not to
antagonize Chinese partners, added that one prominent Chinese university has
barred visiting American scholars from giving lectures if their research did
not conform to the party line.
In
a speech in June, Zhang Yiwei, a senior party official at the influentialChinese Academy of Social Sciences, said
“accepting foreign forces’ point-to-point penetration” was one of the research
institute’s main ideological problems, according to People’s Daily, the
official party newspaper. Mr. Zhang added that his office would not tolerate
any scholar who was not in line with party thought.
Casting
blame on the “black hand” of foreign forces has become increasingly common in
the state news media as well. The People’s Daily has published 42 articles this
year blaming China ’s domestic problems on “Western,” “foreign” or
“overseas” forces, nearly triple the number of similar pieces from the first 10
months of last year, according to a count by the Christian Science Monitor.
The
pro-democracy demonstrations in Hong
Kong have been a favorite
target. Last Friday, Ta Kung Pao, a Hong Kong newspaper close to the party, ran
a front-page story under a headline that said the newspaper had found “ironclad
evidence” that the United States had been secretly plotting the local Occupy
movement since 2006.
The
government has also targeted major Western companies with high-profile investigations and imposed record fines for what
officials call monopolistic practices. Some foreign businesspeople and
officials say the investigations are a form of protectionism.
At the same time, the Chinese government has maintained restrictions on foreign
investment, ownership and market access in many industries.
As a result, American executives have tempered their optimism about doing business here, said John Frisbie, president of the U.S.-China Business Council, a trade group inWashington . “It should be more than a
$350 billion market in China for U.S. companies,” he said. “Many
sectors are still closed. There has generally been a lack of movement forward
on further openings.”
Some have questioned the sincerity — or pointed out the hypocrisy — of the party’s tirades against the West, noting that many party officials have children or other family members living and even applying for citizenship overseas. Mr. Xi’s daughter, Xi Mingze, attendedHarvard University under a pseudonym.
As a result, American executives have tempered their optimism about doing business here, said John Frisbie, president of the U.S.-China Business Council, a trade group in
Some have questioned the sincerity — or pointed out the hypocrisy — of the party’s tirades against the West, noting that many party officials have children or other family members living and even applying for citizenship overseas. Mr. Xi’s daughter, Xi Mingze, attended
“How can
Chinese officials really be anti-American?” asked Zhan Jiang, a media studies
professor at Beijing Foreign Studies University . “Anti-foreign sentiments will always be present in China because of China ’s unique history,” he said. “However, the public’s
opinion of the West will not change because of what the party says.”
Dan
Levin contributed reporting, and Mia Li contributed research.