[Mr.
Haqqani has been accused of having a memo sent in May to Adm. Mike Mullen, then
the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, asking the United States to help
prevent a coup in Pakistan and in exchange offering help with the war on
Islamic militants and an array of other diplomatic and security considerations.]
By
Salman Masood And Waqar Gillani
Joshua Roberts/Bloomberg News |
The
ambassador, Husain Haqqani, returned to Islamabad , the Pakistani capital, on Sunday and met briefly with Mr.
Zardari, according to an aide to the ambassador, who spoke on the condition of
anonymity. The two were planning to meet again on Monday.
Mr.
Haqqani has been accused of having a memo sent in May to Adm. Mike Mullen, then
the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, asking the United States to help
prevent a coup in Pakistan and in exchange offering help with the war on
Islamic militants and an array of other diplomatic and security considerations.
Mr.
Haqqani, who denies having anything to do with the memo, has offered to resign and was recalled by the government to
explain his position.
The main
opposition leader, Nawaz Sharif, a former prime minister, added his voice on
Sunday to those demanding an investigation, saying the government should
determine the authenticity of the memo and its contents within two days.
“Otherwise,
we will move a petition in the Supreme Court for taking action,” Mr. Sharif
warned at a rally of thousands of his supporters in Faisalabad , in Punjab Province . He did not specify the kind of action he had in mind, but
critics have called for punishments ranging from Mr. Haqqani’s resignation to
his prosecution on treason charges.
The claim
that Mr. Haqqani was behind the memo to Admiral Mullen was first made in
October by Mansoor Ijaz, an American businessman of Pakistani origin, who said
Mr. Haqqani had asked him to ensure it was delivered. A former spokesman for
Admiral Mullen said he had received the memo, but did not find it credible and
took no action.
The
unsigned memo, whose authenticity has yet to be ascertained, was published Friday by The News, a leading
English-language newspaper in Pakistan .
Citing a
“dangerous devolution” of security in Pakistan after the killing of Osama bin Laden, and the
possibility of a military coup, the memo asked the United States for “direct
intervention in conveying a strong, urgent and direct message” to the military,
demanding that it end its “brinkmanship.”
In
exchange, according to the memo, Pakistan offered what amounted to an American policy wish list.
The memo
said Pakistan would prosecute any officials found to have been involved in
harboring Bin Laden, hand over the remaining Pakistan-based leadership of Al
Qaeda, allow American forces to conduct military operations against terrorist
groups on Pakistani soil, bring Pakistan’s nuclear program under “a more verifiable,
transparent regime,” eliminate the section of the military intelligence agency
that deals with the Taliban, and cooperate with India in the prosecution of
terrorists.
The News
also published what it said were BlackBerry messages between Mr. Haqqani and Mr. Ijaz that
appeared to show the two discussing details of the memo, with Mr. Haqqani
saying it had been approved by “the boss,” a reference, Mr. Ijaz said, to
President Zardari.
The
ostensible Pakistani offers have inflamed nationalist and opposition
politicians at least as much as the request to press the military to back down.
Mr. Sharif accused President Zardari of “compromising the country’s
sovereignty.”
“This is
the worst disrespect,” Mr. Sharif said. “Writing to another country, asking it
to control our army, instead of resolving matters on our own.”
Mr.
Haqqani has said that he will cooperate with any government inquiry and is
willing to hand over his BlackBerry handsets for forensic examination.
Pakistani
news media reported Sunday that Lt. Gen. Ahmad Shuja Pasha, the head of the
powerful Directorate for Inter-Services Intelligence, or ISI, met with Mr. Ijaz
in London on Oct. 22, where Mr. Ijaz handed over what he said were
his communications with Mr. Haqqani.
An ISI
official declined to comment on the London meeting, but also called for an immediate government
inquiry.
According
to Pakistani news media accounts, President Zardari and Prime Minister Yousaf
Raza Gilani agreed to recall Mr. Haqqani after they were provided with evidence
against him by the army chief, Gen. Ashfaq Parvez Kayani, last week.
Ahmad
Mukhtar, the defense minister, said Sunday that if Mr. Haqqani was involved in
writing the memo, then Mr. Gilani would also be held accountable.
PAKISTANI ENVOY OFFERS TO RESIGN OVER MEMO
[Supporters of Mr. Haqqani say that he maintains close contacts with American officials, including Admiral Mullen, and did not need an intermediary to deliver a message, especially one as explosive and diplomatically delicate as what was said to be included in the memo.]
By
Salman Masood
Mr.
Haqqani denies any involvement with the memo, but he said he offered to resign
to end the continuing controversy.
The claims
that Mr. Haqqani wrote the memo were made by Mansoor Ijaz, an American citizen
of Pakistani origin, who said he was asked to ensure the delivery of the
document to Adm. Mike Mullen, who was
chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff at the time.
Mr. Ijaz
described the memo, which he has not made public, as saying that the civilian
government in Pakistan was seeking help in preventing a possible military coup in
May. The military had just suffered humiliation over the American raid into Pakistan that killed Osama bin Laden.
Mr. Ijaz
said that the memo indicated that Pakistan promised, in return, to dismantle a part of its premier
intelligence agency — which some American officials have come to distrust.
On
Wednesday, Admiral Mullen’s former spokesman, Capt. John Kirby, said that the
memo was delivered, but that Admiral Mullen “did not find the memo at all
credible.”
“Therefore,”
Captain Kirby said, “he addressed it with no one.”
Captain
Kirby added that the memo was unsigned and was delivered by someone other than
Mr. Ijaz.
Supporters
of Mr. Haqqani say that he maintains close contacts with American officials,
including Admiral Mullen, and did not need an intermediary to deliver a
message, especially one as explosive and diplomatically delicate as what was
said to be included in the memo.
The
controversy over the memo threatens to further aggravate the differences
between Pakistan ’s civilian government and the powerful military.
Many
people in Pakistan view Mr. Haqqani as too close to the United States because he often pushes for closer cooperation between the
countries. Before becoming ambassador, Mr. Haqqani was also a vocal critic of
the military, but since taking his job he has sometimes been supportive of the
military in speaking with American officials. Many in the Pakistani military
view him with suspicion.
The prime
minister announced this week that Mr. Haqqani had been told that he needed to
return to Pakistan to answer questions about the memo.
Mr.
Haqqani said the decision of whether he continued at his job or not rested with
President Asif Ali Zardari.
“I do not
want this nonissue of an insignificant memo written by a private individual and
not considered credible by its lone recipient to undermine democracy,” Mr.
Haqqani said in an e-mail.
The news
of the memo first surfaced last month when Mr. Ijaz wrote an op-ed article for
The Financial Times. At the time, he did not name the diplomat he said he was
behind the memo. He only recently said it was Mr. Haqqani.
@ The New York Times (November 17, 2011)