Civilian
atrocities hit headlines almost daily, creating an impression of a spectrum of
attacks – even if links are tenuous
By Jon Henley
A woman lights a candle at a
makeshift memorial in
|
They
are coming, it seems, almost daily. Most – though not all – are in Europe . With weapons ranging from knives to axes, machetes
to handguns, bombs to 19-tonne trucks. At a firework display, a festival, a
fast-food restaurant. On a train and in a church.
In
less than a fortnight, violent, indiscriminate attacks on civilians in France , Germany and, on Monday, in Japan have claimed more than 100 innocent lives –
including those of a four-year-old boy and a priest aged 86.
Some
have plainly been inspired by jihad; four have been claimed by Islamic State. But
others appear to have no particular ideology or motive other than a desire to
kill and maim. All, however, are fanning tensions and fuelling fears.
Most
bear no discernible relation to the coordinated and highly organised attacks on
Paris in January and November 2015 and on Brussels this March, planned and executed by a large
and organised cell of battle-hardened jihadis, many of whom had fought with Isis in Syria or Iraq and returned to Europe on a clear terror mission.
These
attacks – in Nice on 14 July; in Würzburg, Munich, Reutlingen and Ansbach over
the following week; in Sagamihara outside Tokyo on Monday and in the small
Normandy town of St-Etienne-du-Rouvray, near Rouen, on Tuesday – are less clear
in origin.
On
a line that has ideological terrorism at one end and extreme violence triggered
by resentment, rage, personal psychoses and mental health problems at the other,
it is not hard to place Abdelhamid Abaaoud, the radical jihadi behind the
string of suicide bombings and shootings that left 130 people dead in Paris , including 89 at the Bataclan concert hall.
One
of the the two men who slit the throat of Father Jacques Hamel while he was
saying morning prayers on his church at St-Etienne-du-Rouvray on Tuesday
morning was named as Adel Kermiche, 19, who was arrested twice last year while
trying to get to Syria.
Less
clear cut, though, is Mohamed Lahouaiej-Bouhlel, who killed 84 people on
Bastille Day in Nice by mowing them down in a rented truck. Isis swiftly
claimed him as its “soldier”, but prosecutors say he had no meaningful links
with the terror group and showed no particular Islamic fervour (far from it).
Lahouaiej-Bouhlel,
31, did however have a history of violence going back to his childhood in Tunisia and had been treated by psychiatrists with
anti-psychotic and anti-depressant drugs. Isis ’s bloody but simple ideology perhaps simply
gave him what he felt was license to act.
But
Daleel was refused refugee status a year ago and had a history of mental health
problems. An earlier attempt to deport him to Bulgaria had been halted, apparently because of a
knee injury which was, in turn, followed by two suicide attempts.
Police
searching the room of the asylum seeker who attacked train passengers with a
knife and an axe near Würzburg last Monday – an attack also claimed by Isis – found a hand-drawn Isis flag in his notebook.
The
clearly distraught attacker wore a T-shirt bearing the group’s symbol during
the attack, when he shouted “Allahu akbar,” or “God is great”. But officials
have said they are worried by the speed with which he appears to have become
radicalised and suspect he may have been pushed over the edge by recent news of
the death of a close friend.
As
for Ali David Sonboly, the German-Iranian teenager who shot nine people in
Munich dead on Friday before turning his gun on himself, he was bullied at
school, had received treatment for psychological problems and was fascinated
with mass violence, school shootings and by the Norwegian rightwing extremist
Anders Behring Breivik.
The
lack of uniformity or clarity in what is really motivating the current spate of
killings makes it particularly hard to respond to them. The unpredictable
nature of the attacks, and the troubled but often lonely lives of their
perpetrators, means they are necessarily difficult to prevent.
But
with nationalist and anti-immigrant sentiment already on the rise across Europe , and far-right parties ready to capitalise
on every incident, authorities in France and Germany are facing urgent calls to act.
The
fact that three of the recent attacks in Germany were carried out by migrants has heightened
already strong popular misgivings about the refugee policies of the chancellor,
Angela Merkel.
That
three also took place in Bavaria , which has taken many of the 1.1 million refugees who crossed Germany ’s borders last year, and where political
opposition to Merkel’s policy is strongest, makes matters even trickier for the
chancellor, who faces federal elections next year.
(Saying
people were scared and Merkel was “dodging the issue”, Bavarian authorities on
Monday announced a huge increase in controls on migrants and thousands of extra
police to patrol streets and public spaces.)
In
France, too, where the nation came together in horror after both the Charlie
Hebdo shootings and the Bataclan, Stade de France and bar and restaurant killings
of last year, there is now increasing anger at the government’s perceived
incapacity to protect the public. François Hollande, too, faces presidential
elections next year.
But
for many this summer, the politics will be secondary to the fear and anxiety
they feel about what is happening in their countries. It will be no consolation
to learn that western Europe is actually safer now than it has ever been or
that the number of deaths from terrorism is now far lower than through much of
the 1970s and 1980s.
So
is there a unifying factor behind them? One, perhaps. Whatever the underlying
motive behind an individual act of mass violence, the instant, global notoriety
now guaranteed to any disturbed person who carries out such an attack has, surely,
also become a lure.
In
the age of the internet and the camera phone, of 24-hour news, Twitter and
YouTube, one troubled individual’s act of violence will now make them world
famous, immediately, no matter in whose name they do it.